Well I found the problem, if you don't have the actual 10 weapons you won't get the award even if you had them.
When I logged on today I had atleast 10 of every weapon except Dual Blades and Sword and Shield. I had 8 SnS and 9 DBs.
So I made the Altheos Zodiarch and Chalcomatia SnS, then I made my third The Fistolution, checked my guild card and got the award. fuckyouscience